Beautifully written. PD James is a wonderful writer, and I really feel after reading this that I need to increase my vocabulary. I asked once, what should I do to write dialog for a character who is more intelligent than me. Well, I think the character should try and sound like PD James.
from page 16
“If there was time enough or purpose in it, it would be interesting to trace back our common ancestry to discover the roots of this obsessive self-sufficiency. I realize now that it was one of the reasons for my failed marriage. It is probably the reason why Xan never married. It would take a force more powerful than sexual love to prise open the portcullis which defends that crenellated heart and mind.“
About three pages into it, I was very excited to be reading such beautiful writing, and was excited that I would get to talk to my better half about it. (I texted her from a Denny’s to tell her this.)
There is one little thing that was initially bothersome, sometimes it is third person, other times it is a diary entry. That switch between point of view jerked me into remember that I was reading, and stopped the flow.
And there is one BIG thing. I have seen the end of the movie “Children of Men”, and though it is much different than what PD James wrote, I think it is much better, and I feel the end of the movie, matches the tone of the book better. (I have heard from MyBetterHalf that the movie is hardly related to the book, her book review and her movie review). The end of the book, seriously, what the heck!?!!??? It is a horrible ending. Up there with:
- “and then the commies dropped the bomb.”
- “…then Trashcan Man drove in with a semi, & nuked everyone.”
- …it was only a dream…
- Seinfeld’s last episode.
Do read the book, but skip the last five pages, and then watch the last five minutes of the movie. Trust me, it’s for the best.
I’ll give it a B+
oh yeah….dystopia….so, here’s PD James version. Men become infertile, no one knows why, no more babies are born. At first, people think it’s good, because it will ease over population, but then, none. And people start to realize that the human race is about to go extinct with a whimper. As people got more depressed, power was consolidated into the hands of a few. What the people wanted was “protection, comfort, pleasure” (pg 60). The cost: 1) no general elections, 2) the imported indentured servants for slave labor, 3) a govt. sponsored suicide program, 4) all criminals were deported to an anarchy island, 5) mandatory fertility testing.
The male protagonist was going along, as happy as a melancholic divorced historian can be, until a girl comes around, interests him, and introduces him to a different point of view. ( Seriously, is this the formula for dystopia? …boy doing fine, boy meets girl, girl shows him how messed up the world is.)
Sex in this dystopia. Minimal. People have lost interest.
Is there hope for us? I don’t think PD answers that question. What started the dystopia was the ending of th species, and if biology is against us, there is no hope.
(more…)