Gena Showalter’s Playing with Fire was bad. I was wishing I had picked up a Baldacci novel instead.
Story, girl meets boy, girl hates boy, but girl lusts after boy, they are stuck with each other for a week or two, they have a couple of sexual encounters, and decide to live happily ever after because they love each other. The twist, the boy works for a secret society that fights super-powered bad people, and the girl just recently got super-powers.
I didn’t care about the girl. She always had a smart-aleck remark, or an attempt at humor for snappy asides.
After girl wakes up to notice she had stopped breathing a couple of times, and also finding out her father may be in danger… “Whoever picked the brown color scheme needed a serious spanking. Talk about bland. Must have been Rome,….So, Rome needed a spanking, did he? My pleasure.” (pg 220)
later…girl sitting on boy’s lap: “Maybe I was a slot and a harlot (a slot?).” pg 229
later…trying to control her emotions to control her new super-powers, “I let images of sad things float through my mind. Lost puppies. The homeless. Orphaned children….World hunger. The amount of fat grams in a Krispy Kreme.” (pg 236-237)
And another thing, girl has new super-powers, which she quickly learns how to use. No need for hard work, just a couple of afternoons of training, and she is an expert. Evidently super-powers are easier to learn than say…walking, talking, driving a car. At least in cheesy sports movies, they have a training montage scene with bad music playing, that shows how much work the hero puts into their craft.
I don’t know which message is worse to send to young readers…that love is passionate emotion, or that talent trumps training.
Ya know, after this book, I respect someone who says, “I didn’t see myself as a wonderful writer (and still don’t). I saw myself as an apprentice learning a labor intensive, solitary, often frustrating and yet time-honored craft that rarely rewarded its disciples with anything other than the cruelest of rejection.“ Thank you, Mr Baldacci, you write a good essay.